Youm HaShabbos Hazeh or Youm Hamonouach Hazeh?

יותר
30 יונ 2009 13:17 #1095 מאת rallisw
Youm HaShabbos Hazeh or Youm Hamonouach Hazeh? נוצר על ידי rallisw
Both in the brochous following the Shabbos Haftorohous and during Musaf does one say "Youm HaShabbos (V'Youm ....) Hazeh" or "Youm Hamonouach (V'Youm ....) Hazeh"? I understand the recital of "Youm Hamonouach Hazeh" was originally the nusach in Europe and supported by Rashi and others (and cited by the Maharil). This nusach is still retained by the Sephardim and the Taimanim.

Rallis

Minhag Avoseinu Torah Hee!

Please התחברות to join the conversation.

יותר
03 יול 2009 15:19 #1102 מאת Michael
תגובה מMichael בדיון Youm HaShabbos Hazeh or Youm Hamonouach Hazeh?
The Minhag is to say Yom Hashabos Hazeh. The Maharil brings the Minhag of Yom Hamanoach as Minhag Ostreich, and says that although there is a proof from Rashi that he held of this Minhag, he does not understand why they left the Loshon Haposuk "Yom Hashabbos". Yom Hamanoach is the old Minhag Bovel (Babylonia) and Sphorad (Spain).
Historically, Rashi practiced Minhag Tzorfas (France), and Minhag Ostreich is based partially on Minhag France. Minhag France had some influence from Minhag Spain.

Michael FRBSH

Please התחברות to join the conversation.

Powered by פורום קוננה