Mizmor Shir Chanukas Habayis
- SBS
 - מחבר נושא
 - מנותק
 
		פחות
		יותר
		
			
	
		- הודעות 112
 - תודות התקבלו: 0
 
			
	
						12 מרס 2008 04:58				#144
		מאת SBS
	
	
		
			
	
			
			 		
													
	
				Mizmor Shir Chanukas Habayis נוצר על ידי SBS			
			
				What is the minhag regarding the reciting of Mizomor Shir Chanukas. If it isn't said, what is the reason?
Steven
					Steven
Please התחברות to join the conversation.
- Michael
 - מנותק
 
			
	
						12 מרס 2008 05:19				#145
		מאת Michael
	
	
		
			
	
	
			 		
													
	
				תגובה מMichael בדיון Mizmor Shir Chanukas Habayis			
			
				According to minhag Ashkenaz Mizmor Shir was never said.
The saying of Mizmor shir was accepted according to the Sephardi minhag, and the Ariz"l explained it according to the Kabboloh. But according to Minhag Ashkenaz the place to have the mizmor is after Hodu, and there we say Mizmor Lesodah, therefore there is no place for Mizmor Shir over there.
And in addition to this point, the Tur (in אורח חיים, siman נא) brings that there are two minhogim regarding "Hodu". Some say "Hodu" before Boruch She'omar (the Sephardi minhag), and some say it after(Minhag Ashkenaz), and the Tur concludes, that the better way is to say it after Boruch She'omar, because in this way the mizmorim in which we praise Hashem have a Brocho before them (unlike if you say Hodu beforehand - Hodu doesn't have a brocho before it). For the same reason there would be a problem to say Mizmor shir before Boruch She'omar.
Michael
					The saying of Mizmor shir was accepted according to the Sephardi minhag, and the Ariz"l explained it according to the Kabboloh. But according to Minhag Ashkenaz the place to have the mizmor is after Hodu, and there we say Mizmor Lesodah, therefore there is no place for Mizmor Shir over there.
And in addition to this point, the Tur (in אורח חיים, siman נא) brings that there are two minhogim regarding "Hodu". Some say "Hodu" before Boruch She'omar (the Sephardi minhag), and some say it after(Minhag Ashkenaz), and the Tur concludes, that the better way is to say it after Boruch She'omar, because in this way the mizmorim in which we praise Hashem have a Brocho before them (unlike if you say Hodu beforehand - Hodu doesn't have a brocho before it). For the same reason there would be a problem to say Mizmor shir before Boruch She'omar.
Michael
		המשתמש(s) אמרו תודה: Israel 	
			Please התחברות to join the conversation.