Hagbah and Gelilah
- Alexander Weil
- מחבר נושא
- מנותק
פחות
יותר
- הודעות 20
- תודות התקבלו: 0
03 אוג 2008 04:16 #498
מאת Alexander Weil
Hagbah and Gelilah נוצר על ידי Alexander Weil
I am told that at Breuer's, a kotton would not receive the kibbud of hagbah nor gelilah. What is the reason for this?
Alexander
Alexander
Please התחברות to join the conversation.
- Michael
- מנותק
06 אוג 2008 02:27 #510
מאת Michael
תגובה מMichael בדיון Hagbah and Gelilah
The
Divrei Kehillos
says that holding the 2nd or 3rd Sefer Torah, and of course also Houtzo'oh Hagbohoh and Geliloh are not done by a Koton less than 13 years old. In this way there is much more Kovoud Hatouroh, and this would definitely be the way to do in a big community following Minhag Frankfurt (which was a very big community). I would believe this explains the minhag in Breuer's.
On the other hand, the Chavas Yo'ir in his book Mokour Chayim says that there are some that have a minhag not to give a Koton Gliloh, but he concludes that there is no reason to be makpid on this at all. Therefore in young and growing communities there is a place to give the ktanim Gliloh, since the cycle of Aliyos is not so big, and this way more people take part in giving Kovoud to the Seifer Touroh.
Michael FRBSH
On the other hand, the Chavas Yo'ir in his book Mokour Chayim says that there are some that have a minhag not to give a Koton Gliloh, but he concludes that there is no reason to be makpid on this at all. Therefore in young and growing communities there is a place to give the ktanim Gliloh, since the cycle of Aliyos is not so big, and this way more people take part in giving Kovoud to the Seifer Touroh.
Michael FRBSH
Please התחברות to join the conversation.